Study programme and level
|Lectures||Seminar||Tutorial||Druge oblike študija||Individual Work||ECTS|
Fulfillment of requirements to enroll in the 1st year.
Content (Syllabus outline):
I. The constitutional provisions on human rights
1 Systems of regulation
2 Types of rights (individual and collective rights, civil and political rights, economic, social and cultural rights).
3 Historical development of the constitutionality (the idea of constitutionalism, elements of constitutionalism, classical systems of constitutionalism)
II. Constitutional review of the constitutionality (judicial and constitutional review), systems and models.
1 The concept and development of constitutional review (the concept of constitutional review, development of the constitutional review around the world, the definition of constitutional justice, the importance of judicial review of the constitutionality, comparative constitutional review)
2 Systems of constitutional review (non-judicial and judicial system and/or model, the U.S. model, the European model, the mixed model, the French model, the New Commonwealth model, other models, systems without judicial review of constitutionality)
3 Forms of constitutional review (preventive and repressive review, concrete and abstract review, types and legal nature of constitutional decisions, federalism and constitutional justice
4 International Associations of authorities of judicial/constitutional review
1 Protection of human rights
2 National protection. Formal care (ordinary judiciary, special judiciary, constitutional justice). Informal Protection (Ombudsman, other forms of protection, NGOs, etc.).
3 International protection. Universal Protection (United Nations). Regional Protection (European Court of Human Rights, European Union Declaration of 2000 the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, the African Court of Human Rights, the International Court of Human Rights under the Dayton Agreement (Bosnia and Herzegovina)
4 Using of principles of the international protection within the national protection
1 Constitutional review and its methodological characteristics
2 Features of American constitutional review
3 The European constitutional review
4 Basic features of the proceedings before the European Court of Human Rights
5 The European Convention on Human Rights as part of the Slovenian constitutional and. the legal system
5 The fundamental principles of procedure before the Constitutional Court of Slovenia
6 Criteria and principles of constitutional review in Slovenia (the principle of proportionality, new techniques and methods)
1 Constitutional bases for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms
2 Typology of constitutional rights and freedoms
3 Violation of rights, redress and rehabilitation
1 The rule of law (general constitutional principle of proportionality. Prohibition of retroactivity of laws. Protection of legitimate expectations – interference with the vested rights, the requirement of legal certainty and clarity (certainty) of legal norms)
2 Consistency of abstract legal acts.
3 Binding of the administration on the constitution and the law.
4 Duty to justify a specific legal act – Content and scope of reasoning.
6 Publication of laws and regulations (unpublished regulations. Prohibition of secret legislation. Application of the rules that have expired)
SUBSTANTIVE HUMAN RIGHTS – INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS IN SLOVENIAN ( national) environment and environment of the European Convention on Human Rights )
1 The basic concept of ” human rights ”
Human rights in national and international law ; – conceptions of human rights , human freedoms ” human rights ” ( Menschenrechte ) Constitutional Rights ( Grundrechte ) Civil Rights ( Civil Rights ) , personal rights ( Persönlichkeitsrechte ) , fundamental freedoms ( Basic Freedoms , Grundfreiheiten ) ; basic division of human rights , status positivus status negativus ( Jellinek ) ; generations of human rights
2 Historical and philosophical development of human rights
2.1 . Religion and the origin of human rights – traditional Asian culture , Mahayana Buddhism – Ratnagotryibhāga I, vv. 69-7 : Description of the Bodhisattva ; Bible : Ten Commandments ; Qur’an : Suras 12:168-242
2.2 . From natural law to utilitarism
2.3 . The basic historical documents
2.4 . Modern theories of human rights – the ” revised ” naturalistic theory ( Finnis ) ; theory based on distributive justice ( Rawls ) ; theory , based on autonomy ( Gewirth ) ; theory , based on freedom ( Nozick ) ; theory based on equality – egalitarianism ( Dworkin )
3 International grounds of human rights
3.1 . Universal Documents :
3.1.1 . Universal Declaration of Human Rights
3.1.2 . International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
3.1.3 . International Covenant on Social and Economic Rights
3.1.4 . UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide
3.1.5 . Convention on the elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination
3.1.6 . Convention on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women
3.1.7 . Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
3.1.8.The Vienna Declaration
3.1.9 . The Beijing Declaration
3.1.10.The UN Convention on children’s rights
3.2 . Regional documents :
3.2.1 . European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
3.2.2 . The European Social Charter
3.2.3 . American Convention on Human Rights
3.2.4 . The African Charter on Human Rights
3.3 . Methods of implementation of international human rights treaties
3.3.1 . The principle of pacta sund servanda and human rights
3.3.2 . Adoption or transformation of international law into domestic law
3.3.3 . Limitation of state sovereignty
3.3.4.Human as a special subject of international law
4 Particular human rights
4.1 . Right of the first generation :
4.1.1 . Right to life ( death penalty ; Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with the application of biology and medicine; Convention on the Prohibition of genocide ; Statute of the permanent International Criminal Court )
4.1.2.Right to mental and physical integrity – prohibition of torture , prohibition of slavery and forced labor ( current problems ” of modern slavery ,” trafficking , prohibition of trading in human organs ; European Convention for the Prevention of Torture ; international criminal law )
4.1.3.Right to liberty and security (jurisprudence of the ECtHR and the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia )
4.1.4.Right to a fair trial ( analysis of options for preventing ” syndrome of Article 6 “)
4.1.5.Freedom of thought, conscience and religion ( comparative aspects , emphasis on restrictions – Para. 2 of Article 9 of the ECHR )
4.1.6.Freedom of speech, freedom of movement, freedom of association ( comparative aspects , emphasis on restrictions – Para. 2 of Article 10 of the ECHR )
4.1.7.Right to privacy and the family rights ( current problems , protection of personal data ; recent trends in personal and family law )
4.1.8.Prohibition of discrimination ( case-law of the ECtHR )
4.1.9.Right to private property ( current issues )
4.2 . The rights of the second generation (selected chapters, the emphasis on cultural rights)
4.3 . The rights of the third generation ( selected chapters , the emphasis Rights of National Minorities – case study : the Slovenian minority in Italy and Austria )
5 International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights in Armed Conflict ( selected chapters focusing on the Geneva Conventions and their additional protocols and the Statute of the permanent International Criminal Court )
6 International procedures for the protection of the rights of man ( the formal part)
6.1 . Control within the UN system
6.1.1.The Human Rights Board
6.1.2.Commission for Human Rights ( procedures ” 1235 ” and ” 1305 “)
6.1.3.The Board on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination
– The Committee against Torture
– The Commission on the Status of Women
– Options for individual conventions
– Procedure country v. country , the possibility of complaints of individuals and groups
– Other international bodies
6.2 . Procedures on the regional level
6.2.1 . Proceedings before the European Court of Human Rights
– Protocols 11, 14, 15, 16
– Internal Rules of the Court
– Procedures under the European Social Charter
6.2.2 . Control mechanism of the OSCE
7 Open problems in the international human rights law
– Current problems in the international human rights law ( Case Studies )
– Rights of the third generation
– Globalization and Human Rights
– ” Post 11 September ” Trends of Human Rights
Objectives and competences:
Students will be able to find, understand and apply basic knowledge of constitutional law of the Republic of Slovenia.
Intended learning outcomes:
The course enables students to broad and in-depth knowledge of systems and protection of human rights in the world. It is a combination of national and comparative human rights law. As an upgrade to the (national) constitutional law, comparative method informs students about regulations in foreign countries across individual world areas and characteristic types of systems or constitutions. By the process of globalization and the development of communications the comparative approach became a condicio sine qua non of any modern legal expert.
Students learn through formal and informal forms of protection of human rights, in particular the constitutional protection resulting from existing models of judicial/constitutional review.
The existing grounds of human rights law are reflected in national constitutional norms and principles. Moreover, international human rights law and – in Europe – Council of Europe law and European Union law, are strongly influenced by national constitutional law . Although “traditional” systems such as the U.S. , Canada , France and Germany may at first glance serve as a kind of patterns in the search for systemic solutions , the recent constitutional developments in the countries of the new democracy cannot be ignored within the comprehensive presentation of the discussed topic.
Learning and teaching methods:
Lectures are based on the representation of matter with modern computer-based visual means.
Type (examination, oral, coursework, project):
Written Examination 70%
Dokumenti človekovih pravic z uvodnimi pojasnili; Amnesty International Slovenije, Ljubljana 2002.
Mavčič, Arne, Dostop posameznika do sodne presoje ustavnosti in zakonitosti, www.concourts.net – Lectures; Dostop posameznika do sodne presoje ustavnosti in zakonitosti. Dignitas (Ljubl.), 2010, [Št.] 45/46, str. 91-107. [COBISS.SI-ID 393215]
Mavčič, Arne, Zakon o Ustavnem sodišču s pojasnili, Nova revija, Ljubljana, 2000.
Mavčič, Arne, Primerjalno ustavno pravo-pravo človekovih pravic, Pasadena Ljubljana, 2002.
Mavčič, Arne, spletna stran: www.concourts.net.
Človekove pravice – Zbirka mednarodnih dokumentov, I. del (univerzalni dokumenti), Ljubljana 1995.
Človekove pravice-Zbirka mednarodnih dokumentov II. del, Ljubljana 1996.
Šturm, Lovro (ur.), Komentar Ustave Republike Slovenije, FDŠ, Ljubljana 2002 in 2011 (izbrana poglavja).
Spletne strani nosilca predmeta: www.concourts.net.
Spletne strani Komisije Sveta Evrope za demokracijo skozi pravo (Beneške komisije): www.venice.coe.int.
Spletne strani ustavnega sodišča Slovenije: www.us-rs.si.
Spletne strani Evropskega sodišča za človekove pravice: www.echr.coe.int/ ali http://cmiskp.echr.coe.int/tkp197/search.asp?skin=hudoc-en.
Spletne strani OZN: www.un.org.
Spletne strani ustav sveta: http://www.servat.unibe.ch/icl/.
Bulletin on Constitutional Case – Law, Secretariat of the Venice Commision (Council of europe, Strasbourg),ki pa bi ga lahko nadomestili s povezavo, ki je sedaj brezplačna: http://www.codices.coe.int/NXT/gateway.dll?f=templates&fn=default.htm
Reports of fundamental Rights (Fundamental Rights series), European Communities, 2004, 2005, 2003, kar je sedaj brezplačno dosegljivo tudi na povezavi:
Lampe, Rok, Pravo človekovih pravic, Uradni list RS, Ljubljana 2010.
Prof. dr. Arne Marjan Mavčič je diplomiral na Pravni fakulteti Univerze v Ljubljani leta 1970. Po končanem študiju na ljubljanski in zagrebški Pravni fakulteti je doktoriral leta 1979. Od leta 1970 do 1973 je bil pravni svetovalec v tedanjem slovenskem parlamentu, od leta 1974 do 1977 predstojnik Mednarodnega oddelka tedanje Republiške zdravstvene skupnosti. Od leta 1978 do 2002 je bil predstojnik Pravnega infomacijskega centra Ustavnega sodišča Republike Slovenije, po letu 2002 do 2009 pa je bil na istem sodišču predstojnik Službe za analize in mednarodno sodelovanje. Je višji znanstveni svetnik Pravne fakultete ljubljanske univeze in redni profesor za področje pravnih znanosti ter predava na Fakulteti za podiplomske državne in evropske študije in Evropski pravni fakulteti. Deloval je kot oficir za zvezo za Slovenijo pri Beneški komisiji Sveta Evrope in pri Frankofonski zvezi ustavnih sodišč, kot ekspert EU in Sveta Evrope za področje ustavnega sodstva in človekovih pravic, zastopal je Slovenijo v Mreži EU neodvisnih ekspertov za človekove pravice, deloval je kot član Mednarodne zveze za ustavno pravo, Mednarodne zveze pravnikov itd. Kot Fulbrightov štipendist je dalj časa predaval v ZDA, sicer pa stalno predava na seminarjih, konferencah in delavnicah v številnih evropskih in zunajevropskih državah. Deluje kot nacionalni avtor pei Kluwerjevi Enciklopediji ustavnega prava. Njegova bibliografija zajema več kot 300 enot knjig, člankov in drugih strokovnih del v slovenskem in v tujih jezikih, predvsem s področja primerjalnega ustavnega prava, ustavnega sodstva in človekovih pravic (www.concoutrts.net).
Arne Mavčič, D. Law, completed his Bachelor of Law at the University of Ljubljana Law School, Slovenia in 1970, from which, after having completed his post-graduate studies in civil law at the Universities of Zagreb and Ljubljana Law Schools, he was awarded a Doctorate of Law in 1979.
From 1970 to 1973 he was legal advisor to the Slovenian Parliament; from 1974 to 1977 he was Head of the International Department of the Slovenian Health Insurance Association. From 1978 to 2002 he was the Director of the Legal Information Centre of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia, since 2002 until 2009 he was a Head of the Analysis and International Cooperation Department of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia, a Senior Expert Councilor to the University of Ljubljana Law School, specializing in legal information systems and constitutional law, and a Full Professor of Human Rights Law at the Faculty for State and European Studies and at the European Law School.
Dr. Mavčič was the liaison officer for Slovenia on constitutional law and legal information systems to the (Venice) Commission for Democracy through Law under the Council of Europe, was the national correspondent for Slovenia on constitutional law and legal information systems to the ACCPUF Paris, and, a national member for Slovenia of the EU Network of Experts of Human Rights, a member of the International Constitutional Law Association, a member and the national President for Slovenia of the World Jurist Association, was a Fulbright Scholar, an editor of the Collected Slovenian Constitutional Case-Law series, national editor of the East European Case Reporter of Constitutional Law and currently he is a national author for Slovenia of Kluwer's Encyclopedia of Constitutional Law.
He is an editor and author of several other publications in the field of constitutional law as well as an author of over 300 papers and reports on national and international conferences, seminars and workshops. Of late, Dr. Mavčič has predominantly been engaged in practical and promotional activities in the fields of comparative constitutional judiciary and human rights law (www.concourts.net).